Chapter Six:
Sticks and Stones
Olivia threw the door open
so forcefully that it rebounded behind her, slamming back into it’s frame with
a rattling crash that startled the few people loitering outside of One Hogan
Place. Ignoring their surprised stares,
she pushed past them without so much as an ‘excuse me’ as she slammed down the
steps to the sidewalk.
When she reached the curb,
the detective pulled herself to a stop, sucking in deep breaths of cold air
that she expelled from her mouth in plumes of white steam. Turning back, she stared up at the building,
her heart aching in her chest as she tried to process what had just happened.
How could a situation go
from wonderful to crap in so short a time?
Part of her, the part that
had been kicked in the teeth enough in her life, wanted to say fuck it; to just
wash her hands of the whole mess. But a
larger part of her could not ignore the way she had felt when she held Alex in
her arms. The way her self doubts, her
fears, hell even the rest of the world, had ceased to exist. For the first time, sex hadn’t just been
sex. For the first time, she had
actually understood what everyone else was talking about.
Sighing, she tried to rein
in her anger. She knew Alex was scared,
she just couldn’t figure out why or of what.
But then she was a
detective, right?
Her phone rang and Olivia
reached into her jacket, pulling it out to tap it against her forehead a few
times before finally answering it.
“What?” She barked.
“Whoa! What
crawled inside your boxers and died?”
She ground her teeth and
counted to ten before answering. “I don’t
wear boxers. What do you want?”
“Are you ok?” She could hear the concern in
Elliot’s voice and tried to drag her frustration down a notch. “What
happened? Did Cabot chew you out or
something?”
Olivia snorted, a bitter
laugh escaping her lips. “Something like
that.”
“So I take it we’re not getting the warrant for
Tate’s financials?”
“No, I got it. She said it would be there within the
hour. Can you get the ball rolling on
that? I have to stop off at my apartment
on the way back.”
Elliot laughed lightly. “You
always did have a way with Cabot. From
now on you get to go whenever we need anything.”
“Yeah, yeah, whatever. Can you cover for me?”
“Sure, but what’s at your apartment?”
“My common sense?” She sighed.
“I just got too close to the curb and a cabbie decided to give me a
bath. I need a shower and some dry
clothes. I’ll be back at the precinct
within the hour, okay?”
“Yeah, sure.
I’ll see you then partner.”
* * * * * * * * * *
Olivia stepped out of the
shower, using a towel to dry her hair before wrapping it around her torso. She pulled open her medicine cabinet and
dipped her fingers into a jar of gel on the bottom shelf. Closing the mirror, she leaned in close as
she tumbled her brown locks between her fingers, scowling at herself for a
moment before stepping back. When she
did, her eyes grew wide as she took in the pale purple bruises scattered across
her shoulders.
Reaching up, she touched
them gently, surprised that she had marked at all; usually her skin coloring
hid that sort of thing. For them to
show, Alex’s grip would have to have been intense.
Swallowing, she closed her
eyes as memories of that afternoon flashed through her mind. Alex’s hands in her hair, wrapped around her
shoulders… digging into her back. She
opened her eyes and stared at herself as she remembered the taste of blood on
the blonde’s tongue. She gently pulled
at her lower lip, wincing when she saw the angry red line of the cut that had
been reopened when Alex bit her. She
hadn’t felt it at the time; she had been busy feeling too many other
things. But now that she was aware of
it, it stung like a bitch and she knew it would drive her crazy.
Not just because of the
pain, but because it would make her think about what she had shared with the beautiful
young lawyer who now seemed to want nothing to do with her.
* * * * * * * * * *
“Liv!” Elliot grinned at his partner as she walked
into the observation room. “Jackpot!”
“DNA match?” She asked in disbelief.
“Well, no.” He shook his head. “Serra Tate was not the mystery guest in
Wainscott’s bed that night. But this is
almost as good.”
Olivia glanced through the
two way mirror and saw Serra sitting in the same position she had been in
earlier. “Has she been in there this
whole time?”
“Huh?” Her partner glanced at the blonde and
shrugged. “I guess so why?”
“Because she’s not a perp,
Elliot! She’s just a girl that found
herself in a bad situation!”
“More than one, apparently.”
Olivia arched an
eyebrow. “What do you mean?”
He handed her a
printout. “This came over five minutes
ago from First Mutual.”
She read over the
information, a sinking feeling in her stomach when she realized what it
was. “Come on.”
Elliot followed her into the
room, standing attentively beside Tate this time as Olivia slammed the paper
down on the table in front of the startled blonde.
“You want to tell me what
the fuck that is, Serra?”
“Wha…what?” She leaned forward and glance at the
printout, paling slightly. “I can
explain.”
“You can explain?” Olivia rolled her eyes before dropping into a
chair. “Ok, then please explain how a
hundred and fifty thousand dollar check from Preston Industries managed to find
its way into your bank account a month and a half ago?”
Serra stared down at the
statement, her mouth opening and closing as though she were trying to think of
something to say.
“Spill it!” Olivia ordered. “Otherwise you’re definitely going to need
that lawyer you mentioned earlier!”
“Samuel Wainscott.” She whispered.
“What?”
She covered her face with
her hands. “Samuel Wainscott! He paid me
off. He gave me that money to leave
Sammy.”
Olivia’s forehead furrowed
in confusion. “You’re telling me that
Sam Wainscott gave you a hundred and fifty thousand dollars to leave his
daughter a month and half ago? That
doesn’t make any sense.”
“You think I don’t know
that?” Serra snapped. “When that asshole he had following me showed
up at the bookstore with the check, I thought it was some kind of trick. I mean, why would he pay me to leave her when
I already had?” She rubbed her temples.
“I figured it was just a bribe to keep me away from her; Sammy had been pretty adamant about me coming
back when I first left. Anyway, I was
broke… I didn’t work while I was with her and there was no way I was going to
make my tuition next year-“
“So you took it.” Olivia’s lip curled in disdain.
Serra squared her shoulders
and lifted her chin. “I said I wasn’t a
dog, detective, I didn’t say I was a fool!
Look, I know it wasn’t my best moment, but that man made us miserable
every chance he got. He belittled her
and harassed me all because he thought that I had corrupted his little
girl. And no matter how many times Sammy
told him that she had pursued me, he kept hanging onto the idea that I was the
antichrist! I deserved something for the
hell he put us through.” She
shrugged. “It isn’t like I broke the
law. He offered the money and I took
it. I wasn’t with Sammy anymore so it
wasn’t even under false pretenses.”
“And that makes it ok?” Olivia asked softly.
Serra stared at her for a
long time before replying. “No. It doesn’t.
But it made it easier.”
The brunette sat back in her
chair as she watched the young woman closely.
She knew in her gut that Serra was telling her the truth. “Alright.” She stood up. “You’re free to go.”
“What?” Elliot and Serra both barked in
disbelief.
“What about the
assault?” Her partner demanded.
Olivia locked her eyes with
Serra’s. “I’m not pressing charges at
this time.” She pointed at her. “But you stay local, and you let those
friends of yours know that if we come looking for you and they start playing
games, it’s going to land your ass right back behind bars. Deal?”
Tears of relief flooded
Serra’s eyes. “Deal.” She nodded eagerly. “Detective?”
“Hmm?”
“That woman I told you
about… the one Sammy was involved with.
Who ever she is, she knows more about Sammy’s life over the last few
months than I ever could. She knows all
of the dark stuff that I couldn’t stomach.
I have to live with the fact that I walked out on Sammy, probably when
she needed me the most. I couldn’t live
knowing that her killer got away with it.
Find her… please.”
The detective looked at the
young woman compassionately. “I intend
to.”
* * * * * * * * * *
Saturday 06:11 PM
Olivia looked up at the
non-descript exterior of 1655 Park West and then down at the clothes she was
wearing. She doubted her skin tight
Levi’s, corded Henley and black leather jacket would make much of an impression
on the doorman, but if Zoey had been telling her the truth, she had an
automatic in.
Stepping up to the door, she
almost laughed when the uniformed man raised his eyebrows at her in
surprise. His hand came up automatically
and he opened his mouth to speak.
She didn’t give him the
chance; instead she pulled the keychain from her inside coat pocket. She allowed the ring to slide down her middle
finger so that the crystal dangled in the center of her palm, creating a blood
red halo as it reflected the light from overhead.
His whole countenance changed
in an instant, going from slightly disdainful to warmly respectful in a blink
of an eye. Smiling, he opened the door
for her as he bowed slightly and said, “Have a pleasant evening, ma’am.”
When she got to the
penthouse, she was surprised by how empty it was. Glancing at her watch she realized that it
was only a little after six, still pretty early as far as the bar circuit
went. Her eyes quickly scanned through
the women present, taking note of everyone and everything.
“She’s not here.”
The familiar voice made her
turn towards the bar where Zoey was polishing glasses, getting ready for the
Saturday night rush. “I know.” She nodded as she slid onto a stool. “That’s why I am.”
“Ouch!” The bartender
grimaced. “I take it you’re still on the
outs with the beautiful Ms. Cabot?”
“Not for lack of
trying. I… talked to her this
afternoon.”
“Talked?” Zoey gave her a knowing wink. “So how’d that go?”
“Pretty well at first.” Olivia didn’t understand why she felt
comfortable talking to the younger woman, but she was grateful for her presence
and her ear. “Then I got
blindsided.” She sighed. “Maybe… maybe I’m just barking up the wrong
lesbian, you know? Like you said, she’s
got the Big Three. What have I got? A tiny apartment, a city wage, and a job that
takes up ninety percent of my life… I
mean look at me! The doorman wasn’t even
going to let me in here until I flashed that lucky charm you gave me.”
“I know some other thing’s
you’ve got.”
“What?”
Zoey tossed the bar rag on
the counter and leaned on her arms.
“You’ve got a killer smile, incredible eyes, and you look pretty damn
good in a leather jacket.” She
grinned. “And since Cabot knew you
before you came in here and still planted that kiss on you? I’d say there’s a whole lot more to you than
just the way you look.”
Olivia blinked. “Why would you think that?”
“Velvet gets best of high
society, Olivia.” She smirked. “The lesbian cream that rises to the
top. Cabot’s been coming here for a
while; I’ve seen people approach her and I’ve watched her shoot them down. That woman has sent back enough drinks to
stock the bar for a year. But I have
never seen her look at another woman the way she looked at you. And I have also never seen her cross the bar
to talk to anyone. For her to do that,
you would have to be very special indeed.”
The detective shrugged,
turning to hide the faint blush that crept into her cheeks.
“Sexy and shy!” Zoey chuckled. “Something tells me I’m meeting the real
Olivia now.”
She grinned ruefully and held
out her hand. “Detective Olivia Benson,
and yes, this is the real me. I swear too much, I laugh too loud and I live
in jeans and t-shirts six days out of the week.” She glanced around. “Guess I’m not what you would consider your
regular clientele.”
“Ooo a cop!” Zoey laughed.
“I wish.” She placed a shot glass
on the bar and filled it up with Jack, nudging it towards the detective when
she didn’t reach for it immediately.
“Believe it or not, this isn’t exactly what I pictured when I decided to
open this place.”
“What did you picture?”
“Something simple, a little
more down to earth; but then my grandmother always said that buildings have
souls of their own. I may own it; I may
have designed the layouts, but the spirit… that was always here.”
Olivia nodded, then Zoey’s
words registered and she looked up in mild shock. “You…own the building? The whole
building?”
She nodded.
“Who the hell was your
grandmother?”
“Ivy Merrin.”
“Merrin, Merrin..” The detective racked her brain trying to make
a connection. “Never heard of her.”
Zoey laughed. “Why would you? She was a secretary.” Her eyes sparkled as she realized what the
older woman meant. “Ahhh! You were trying to find the royalty in my
family tree. Let me save you the
trouble, there isn’t any. My father was
a truck driver and my mother was a hair stylist.”
Olivia blinked. “Then how…?”
“A royal line has to start
somewhere right?” The bartended refilled
her empty glass. “I was an art major in
college. Ran into some luck when I was
bumming around Versailles my first year out.
I found a patron who was very… appreciative of my skills. She taught me how to paint what would sell,
among other things. I came back from
Europe with some serious coin in my pocket and the even more valuable skill of
being able to remain friends with my exes.”
“I don’t understand.”
Zoey sighed. “Well, when I got back, I met and fell in
love with two very successful women.
First it was Natalia, plastic surgeon to New York’s elite, and then it
was Francine, the investment banker with a heart. The relationships didn’t
last, but the friendships did. I showed
them my business plans and they jumped at a chance to invest. I own fifty two percent of this place, they
split the difference.”
Olivia raised her eyebrows. “Color me impressed!” She downed the second shot. “So, what do you do with the rest of the
building?”
“The first three floors are
office space; gay owned businesses mostly.
They get a good deal on rent; I get to do my part for the community and
take a tax write off on the shortfall.”
She shrugged. “The rest of the
floors are cut up into studios, lofts and apartments. Again, there are rent shortfalls but the
income from the rest of the building more than makes up for it.”
“The rest…?”
“Yeah, the penthouse… and
the basement.”
Olivia blinked. “What’s in the basement?”
Zoey looked at her with a
blatantly wicked expression on her face.
“Why… Hell, Detective.”
* * * * * * * * * * *
The elevator opened into a
dimly lit hallway. Sconces lined the walls on either side and red bulbs shining
up at the ceiling gave the small space a surreal quality. Olivia could see a staircase curving up out
of sight at the other end. “Where does
that go?” She pointed.
“Up to the street.” Zoey grinned.
“But we’re going this way.” She
led the detective to a large ornate iron door to their left and Olivia had to
stifle a laugh when the bartender produced an elaborate skeleton key to slip
into the lock.
“You’re joking with that key
right?”
The blonde shrugged. “Appearances are everything.” The door swung open into complete darkness
and Olivia reached out, placing her hand within an inch of Zoey’s back, using
the younger woman’s body heat to follow closely behind her.
There was the sound of some
kind of switch being thrown and a series of lamps lining the ceiling started to
glow dully as they began to heat up.
After a few moments, Olivia was able to see clearly enough to make out
the large space around her.
It left her speechless.
The basement was the same size
as the Penthouse, but set up in an entirely different layout and theme. Where Velvet was all chic and ambience, gauzy
curtains and light colors, the basement was decked out in deep blues and
purples, the walls were painted black, the mood lighting supplied by the dozens
of wrought iron fixtures strategically scattered throughout.
To one side was the main
room, which had a bar made of black and gray marble, surrounded by red
leather-covered stools and snooker tables with black felt and crimson colored
balls. There was also a dance floor and
a small raised stage that looked like it had been well used.
To the other side was a
hallway made up of thick midnight blue and black drapes that hung from the
ceiling on iron rails. The same types of
drapes had been used to create small private alcoves along each side, complete
with either couches or beds; the back wall of each alcove was exposed brick
that had been fitted with numerous iron hooks at various heights.
“What the hell is
this?” Olivia breathed.
“This?” Zoey turned in a
half circle, her arms held out. “This is Suede.”
“Suede?”
“Like I said before, if
Velvet is heaven, then Suede is hell.”
She shrugged. “This is Natalia’s
baby. Her own private little dungeon.”
The detective’s eyes
narrowed. “What goes on down here,
Zoey?”
The bartender held up her
hands. “Nothing like that, detective!” She tsked as though she were offended. “People can bring their own toys. The can play at bondage and domination, they
can spank, tickle, tease… whatever… but NO sex.
If the bouncers catch that going on, the client is eighty-sixed
permanently.”
Olivia turned in a circle,
her mouth opening and closing slowly. “I
don’t even know what to say. How do you
get insurance for this place?”
“We have strict safety
policies in place. Anyone who walks down
that hallway has to have reservation and a signed waiver and declaration of
intent on file. We keep good records and
so far, we’ve never had a problem.”
“So… when you said to stick
to Wednesdays, Fridays and Saturdays it was because…”
“Because the rest of the
week Velvet is dark and Suede is open.
We had them both open six days a week at first, until it turned out that
a lot of our clientele wanted to use both clubs, but didn’t necessarily want to
be seen jumping the gates. So we gave
Suede its own street entrance and didn’t allow traffic between the two
anymore. Except of course, when someone
like Alex Cabot needs an out…” She
teased. When she didn’t get a response
she waved her hand in front of the brunette’s face. “Olivia?”
The detective’s demeanor had
changed completely. “I can’t believe she
didn’t tell me about this.”
“Who? Alex?”
Olivia nodded sullenly.
“Look, Liv,” The bartender
shook her head. “Alex didn’t really know
about this place. Suede has a pretty
specific crowd and it is by invitation only. The one time I approached her
about it I got as far as the word ‘leather’ and the look on her face told me in
no uncertain terms that drinks with the girls was all good, but anything else
was not an option. It’s not like Suede
is a place to hang out and relax.” She
smirked. “Well, not that kind of relax…”
“This is where Samantha
Wainscott came to play, isn’t it Zoey?”
“Sammy? Yeah, she spent time
here.” She said cautiously. “Why?”
Olivia felt like slapping
herself. She had been so busy spilling
her guts to the younger woman that she had ignored one of the cardinal rules of
investigation.
The bartender always knows something.
“Okay, let’s start
over.” She took a deep breath and pulled
out her shield. “I’m Detective Olivia
Benson, and I need to ask you some questions in regards to the death of
Samantha Wainscott.”
* * * * * * * * * * *
Olivia sat quietly at the
black marble bar, watching Zoey as she downed her fourth shot. The bartender had called upstairs an hour
earlier to tell her bar back, Melissa, to cover for her and then proceeded to
crack open a very expensive bottle of tequila.
Olivia had matched her for the first three shots and then stopped,
wanting to keep her head at least somewhat clear, even if she wasn’t
technically on the clock.
“I can’t believe Sammy’s
dead.” Zoey whispered sadly. “I mean, the girl had issues but she was a
good person.” She gave the detective a hard
look. “You know you could have told me
you were investigating her death. You
could have trusted me.”
Olivia had the grace to
flush slightly. “I am sorry, Zoey. But I have to follow standard procedure. If it makes you feel any better I was going
to talk to you about it tonight. Serra
gave us some information about a woman that Sammy was seeing, that she had met
her at ‘the bar’. I just assumed the bar was Velvet.”
“Sammy never brought anyone
to Velvet but Serra. I know she got
approached by a lot of other women…”
“This one would have had an
affinity for black leather gloves.”
Zoey’s eyes met hers quickly
and then slid away.
“You know who I’m talking
about.”
“I don’t know her name. The only time I ever saw her upstairs was
when she was on the hunt. And her prey
was usually Sammy. I know she spent a lot of time down here, but like I said
Suede is Natalia’s domain. What people
choose to do is their own business, as long as they don’t try to do it to
me. And I don’t watch.”
Olivia nodded slowly. “But you have records. If they spent time in one of those alcoves
together you would have their signed waivers and both their names on the
reservation right?”
Zoey nodded slowly.
“Well?” Olivia’s patience was wearing thin. “Can I see the records?”
The bartender sighed. “Yes… with a court order.”
“What?” The detective’s jaw dropped.
“Look, Olivia, I like you, I
do. And if it were just my ass on the
line, I would give you the files. But
our clients rely on our discretion and this is a business where all that
matters is the client. I can’t just hand
out their private information because you asked me for it. I won’t fight a court order, but you have to
understand why I need you to get one.”
“Fine.” Olivia muttered under her breath. “You do realize what I have to do to get it
right?”
The spark returned to Zoey’s
eyes for the first time since she learned of Samantha’s death. “Let me guess… you have to ‘talk’ to
Alexandra Cabot again?” She snickered. “Is that such a bad thing?”
The detective glared at her.
“Ooookay!” She poured them both another shot. “In that case, I say we stay right here until
we figure out a plan to get you back into that woman’s good graces.”
Olivia picked up her shot
glass and knocked it back. “I don’t
think you have enough tequila for that.”
Zoey slapped the shot
glasses aside, setting two tumblers in their place on the bar. “Let’s test that theory, shall we?”
* * * * * * * * * *
Oh my god…
Olivia groaned loudly as she
cracked her eyes open, only to quickly slam them shut again when the light from
the open window made her brain feel like it was three sizes too big for her
skull.
Grabbing a pillow from the
other side of the bed, she slammed it down on her face; willing to risk
suffocation if it meant blocking out the sun.
After a few moments, the pain receded slightly and she was able to think
again.
Unfortunately, the first
thought that popped into her head was that the pillow on her face smelled like
someone else’s hair, which caused her to pull it away quickly, letting the
sunlight back in.
Sitting up, she rubbed her
temples firmly with her fingertips as she looked around the room.
Queen sized bed, dresser,
end tables, and a door leading to the bathroom… yep, it was a bedroom.
Too bad it wasn’t hers.
She pulled the blanket away
and looked down at herself. T-shirt
but no bra, briefs but no jeans… Damn, that could mean anything!
“Good morning beautiful!”
Olivia turned towards the
voice to find Zoey standing in the doorway holding a glass. Her hair was tousled, her body covered by an
oversized t-shirt that left far too little to the imagination. “Shit.”
She grumbled.
Zoey laughed. “Well, aren’t you a little fucking ray of
sunshine?”
“Sorry.” The detective mumbled. Then she stared at the blonde
suspiciously. “Why the hell do you look
so good? You drank more than I did!”
She climbed onto the bed
next to Olivia and held out the glass.
It was filled with a thick looking sludge that seemed to glow a bright
orange-green color. “I call it The Bitch
That Bit Ya. It’s kind of like ‘the hair
o’ the dog’ times ten.”
Olivia leaned forward and
sniffed the contents of the glass, pulling her head away quickly as her
nostrils began to burn. “What the hell
is in that?”
Zoey patted her gently on
the leg. “Trust me, you don’t want to know.
I suggest plugging your nose, closing your eyes, and downing it in one
big gulp.”
“I don’t think so…” She tried to push the glass away from her.
“So you want to go see Alex
looking like ten pounds of wet dog shit and feeling like a bucket of fuck?”
Olivia blinked. With a sheepish look, she took the offered
glass and brought it to her lips.
“No, really, close your
eyes.” Zoey smirked. “Otherwise the
color will make you dizzy.”
The detective did as she was
told. The liquid had the consistency of
hot fudge and a flavor she would be eternally grateful that she had no frame of
reference for. She was barely able to
hang on to her gag reflex by using every trick she had ever employed at a crime
scene.
When she was finally done
and fairly certain that the vile concoction wasn’t going to reappear, she
handed the glass back to Zoey, arching one eyebrow curiously when the bartender
leaned over the side of the bed and dropped it into the trash can.
“I’ve never been able to get
the smell out of the glass.” Zoey
smirked.
“Wonderful.” She ran her tongue over her teeth. “How long will it take to get it out of my
mouth?”
The younger woman smiled,
leaning in so close that Olivia could feel her breath against her lips. “Do you want to find out?”
The brunette looked down at
the hand still lying casually on her leg, swallowing when long, supple fingers
started stroking softly up the inside of her thigh. “Uh…”
She pulled herself up against the headboard. “What the hell happened last night?”
Zoey followed her, keeping the
distance between their bodies to a minimum.
“You mean you don’t remember?”
“No… “She grabbed the hand
that had jumped up to her belly.
“Zoey! Look, you’re a nice girl
and all, but whatever happened… I-“
“Passed out.” The bartender finished for her, before
kissing her sweetly on the lips.
“Passed out?”
“Yup!” Zoey grinned.
“We’re in my crash pad, one floor down from Velvet. I had to have two of the bouncers help me get
you up here. You should have told me you
don’t do well with tequila.”
“So… Nothing happened?”
“Well, you did spoon me all
night. But I thought that was kind of
sweet.” She laughed at the flush that
colored the older woman’s face. “Other
than that, you were a perfect gentleman; which is a good thing, because you’re
really not my type. I like my women a
bit less perfect and a lot more needy.”
She patted her on the shoulder.
“Besides, I don’t mess with women in love…”
“Whoa!” Olivia held her hand up to stop the
snickering blonde. “Who said I was in
love?”
Zoey rolled her eyes. “Like
you need to say it, Detective Obvious?
Or would that be…Detective Oblivious?”
She laughed and jumped away when Olivia lunged at her. “Don’t even try it! I’m younger and quicker. Now get dressed. You have to go see your woman!”